Wednesday, October 5, 2011

SPLC reaction- due October 7

"I heart boobies" campaign debate

Legal Issues
1. opinion privalge- because they are choosing to support the breast cancer campaign
2. censorship- because they are not allowing the students freedom of speech


Summary
    After a Pennsylvania middle school made a failed attempt at banning the “I Heart Boobies” breast cancer awareness slogan, Sauk Prairie Middle School in Wisconsin is attempting to do the same. A student at the Wisconsin school has filed a lawsuit saying that the ban violates her First Amendment rights.
Kaisey Jenkins and her classmates wore the bracelets and t-shirt for most of the first semester of 2010 without getting in any trouble. But before the second semester, the principal announced out of the blue that anything bearing the “I Heart Boobies” slogan would be expelled. Instead, Jenkins and her mother tried to talk to the school district and the principal to discuss the violation of student free speech. They hoped to get the policy reversed but it didn't work. They claimed the “I Heart Boobies” bracelet was unconstitutional and in April, a federal judge agreed. The case is now being appealed to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
    I think that there is nothing wrong with the "I heart boobies" campaign because it is promoting breast cancer awareness and students have the right to express what they want to support. The bracelets don't say anything wrong or really innapropriate, not anything we don't hear in the hallways or even in health class. I think it isn't wrong to be educated about things in our world, even if they are a little harsh or innapropriate, we can't hide from the truth.

No comments:

Post a Comment